3. The Wauwinet
Popular with honeymooners, The Wauwinet sits in a quieter northern corner of Nantucket island, less than 2 miles from the Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge. Here, you can stretch out your sea legs on one of two private beaches or sample the local seafood at the ever-popular TOPPER’s restaurant. The attentive service staff deserves a mention as well: Everyone, from the reservations assistants to the cleaning staff, receives high praise from guests. The concierge even makes pre-vacation planning phone calls. The luxurious rooms and cottages, outfitted in soothing muted tones with wooden furnishings, free Wi-Fi access and 400-thread-count Pratesi linens, leave guests vying for more time at this romantic retreat. Also included in your room rate: coffee and pastries in the morning and evening port and cheese. Because The Wauwinet is a member of the Relais & Châteaux family, Club 5C members can earn or redeem points here for additional benefits. Keep in mind: The Wauwinet is a seasonal property, open from late April to the end of October.
4. Mayflower Inn & Spa, Auberge Resorts Collection
Nestled in the tiny town of Washington near the western edge of Connecticut about 92 miles northeast of New York City, the Mayflower Inn & Spa earns its romantic reputation according to past visitors. The entire property is quaint and calming, with a startlingly wide spectrum of white and cream colors on display. Guests adore the spacious guestrooms that feature classic New England decorations, including canopied beds and historical artwork. The spa is also beautifully designed, with a romantic ambiance of pastel hues and more contemporary patterns. Guests say the spa’s services, which range from relaxing massages to Pilates classes, left them feeling rejuvenated. The hotel also features an acclaimed restaurant, which serves up dishes classic, seasonal dishes.