Best Food Subscription Boxes, Tested by Food & Nutrition Experts




Meat DeliveryButcherBox Meat Delivery

Get high-quality butcher cuts of your favorite meats and seafoods from this subscription service that delivers directly to your door. Select from one of four boxes: custom boxes allow you to create your own box and choose from more than 25 high-quality cuts; mixed boxes come with a selection of 100% grass-fed beef, free-range organic chicken and pork raised crate-free; and the last two box types are beef and chicken only or beef and pork only. Both GH experts and at-home testers were thoroughly impressed with the quality and variety of the meats that the service provides.

All beef is 100% grass-fed and grass-finished, and the seafood was top-notch, making this a super versatile option for all eaters. Even the chicken nuggets scored rave reviews in our tests. Everything arrives frozen, so be sure to have plenty of freezer space available upon delivery!

Wild Caught SeafoodSizzlefish Wild Caught Seafood

Sizzlefish delivers high-quality seafood directly to your door, including wild Alaskan King salmon, wild Gulf shrimp, scallops, clams, crab and more. Our experts raved about the freshness of the fish, and testers described the service as “absolutely excellent” and “exceptional quality.”

One tester said, “There are not enough words to describe how tender, juicy and flavorful all of the fish tasted!” Both experts and testers agreed that the packaging was exceptional and everything arrived ice cold, even in the warm summer months. Take note that the subscription box requirements are somewhat large: They start at 14 portions.